but I don't think I was alone in the whole thing," she says,
adding that it was not her intent to deceive.
"I was trying to present it even better."
-Kristin Roovers
In Jeffrey Young's article, "Journals Find Many Images in Research Are Faked," Ms. Roovers is quoted (shown above) where she attempts to justify the manipulation of one of the images from her research. Although she admits to altering the image, she does not hesitate in mentioning the involvement of others. However, that does not exempt her from the fact that she knew manipulating the image was wrong, but did it regardless. What good does it do to "present it even better" if the outcome nearly ended your career?
Furthermore, the idea that Ms. Roovers "little stunt" postponed what could have been a breakthrough in the research of cell growth in diabetes angers me. My roommate/best friend is diabetic, and I see first hand how much of a struggle it can be.
Presenting something in a way unlike its true form is deception, regardless of intent.
Here is my photo that lies:
I chose a photograph of Hitler, because I am thoroughly interested in how photo alterations played a great role in our history. I was not aware of how many famous photographs actually have been altered. Also because I wanted to make fun of Hitler. Before I began searching for an image, I knew I wanted it to be Hitler making some sort of speech because I wanted his mouth open for the kitty-eating. Google helped me located just what I needed!
I used the magic lasso on Photo-shop to place the kitty on his hand. The kitty image was actually in color and larger, so I had to decrease its size, and convert it to black and white. I played around with the hue/saturation and brightness/contrast tools until I found a happy medium. I had to use the "healing brush" and "smudge tool" to blend the kitty into the Hitler image. In order to obtain some of the grain that was in the original photograph, I had to use one of the grain filters on my kitty layer. Lastly, I used the smart brush tool and applied the "yellow photo" application and then played with the hue/saturation tools again.
I manipulated this photo of Hitler because most of the photo altering of world leaders is never really nice. I wanted to poke fun at someone who actually deserves it. Although I am against photo manipulation when it is more than just touching up blemishes on my senior pictures, for example, I do not think it was harmful in this case. No kittens were harmed in the process, and there have been worse things said about Hitler. That is my story and I am sticking to it!
Works Cited:
Young, Jeffrey R. "Journals Find Many Images in Research Are Faked. (Cover story)." Chronicle of Higher Education 54.39 (2008): A1-A11. Academic Search Complete. EBSCO. Web. 11 Nov. 2009.

